WORLD / Health
Firstborn sons have higher IQ - study
(Reuters)
Updated: 2007-06-22 09:12
WASHINGTON - Firstborn sons have higher IQs than their younger brothers,
and their social status within the family may explain why, researchers
reported on Thursday.
A study that used military draft records for more than 240,000 Norwegian
men found that firstborns had an edge of 2.3 IQ points on their next
oldest brothers, who in turn beat brothers born third by 1.1 points on
average.
Men who had been raised as the eldest, whether they were born first,
second, or third, had IQs to match their first-born peers. The same was
true for those raised or born second, Petter Kristensen and colleagues at
the University of Oslo report in the journals Science and Intelligence.
"This study provides evidence that the relation between birth order and
IQ score is dependent on the social rank in the family and not birth
order as such," Kristensen's team wrote in Science.
Their studies confirmed what many scientists had suspected for more than
a century - that firstborns have an edge.
But attempts to prove the effect have been disputed, in part because the
circumstances of each family are different.
To compensate for this, Kristensen's team studied brothers raised in the
same families.
And some scientists argue that birth order IQ differences arise in the
womb, while others point to family interactions.
To distill potential biological effects from social effects, Kristensen's
team dug up the young mens' family birth records and found families whose
first-born or first- and second-born children had died before the age of
one year.
Larger share of family resource?
That was when they discovered that it was not birth order so much as
growing up as the eldest of the children in a family that made the
difference.
Kristensen said the findings fit with most existing theories about why
merely being older might affect someone's IQ.
Various researchers have suggested that older siblings might benefit from
a larger share of family resources, the process of tutoring their younger
brothers and sisters, or from expectations placed on their social rank.
"Things like intellectual resources (and) stimulation from the parents to
the child seem to be very important," Kristensen said in a telephone
interview.
The findings swayed even skeptics of the theory that birth order affects
intelligence.
"Birth order has been studied in relation to everything you can think
of," said Joe Rodgers, a professor of psychology at the University of
Oklahoma who was not involved in the research.
He said he was impressed that Kristensen's team was able to document a
2.3-point difference in IQ in such a large group.
"An awful lot of parents would pay money if their kids could increase IQ
by two real IQ points," Rodgers said in a telephone interview.
The IQ differences were larger in brothers born into smaller families,
and to married women with higher education. But the effect seems to
vanish with greater age gaps between siblings, Kristensen's team wrote in
the journal Intelligence.
It is unclear what the gap means for individual families, and if it can
be found outside this population of young Norwegian men.
"I don't think it would surprise anyone that life is different in Norway
than it is in the United States," Rodgers said.
However, "there is no reason to suspect that this should not be valid
concerning women as well as men," Kristensen said.
He said he would be interested to see how siblings compare in cultures in
which extended family members live together.
Top World News
� H5N1 bird flu virus confirmed in Czech Republic
� US military: 14 troops killed in Iraq
� US nuclear envoy visits N.Korea
� Nigerian troops kill 12 at Italian oil facility
� Bush eyes Blair for Mideast peace role
Today's Top News
� Nation set to substantially forgive Iraq debt
� New plea to save 'lost' kids
� Ban on use of corn for ethanol lauded
� US military: 14 troops killed in Iraq
� Shanxi governor makes self-criticism for slave labor
Most Commented/Read Stories in 48 Hours
Learn Chinese, Chinese Course, Learn mandarin, Learning Materials, Mandarin audio lessons, Chinese writing lessons, Chinese vocabulary lists, About chinese characters, News in Chinese, Go to China, Travel to China, Study in China, Teach in China, Dictionaries, Learn Chinese Painting, Your name in Chinese, Chinese calligraphy, Chinese songs, Chinese proverbs, Chinese poetry, Chinese tattoo, Beijing 2008 Olympics, Mandarin Phrasebook, Chinese editor, Pinyin editor, China Travel, Travel to Beijing, Travel to Tibet
